What about questions seeking help for coding challenges?

Coding Challenge Coding Live

Sign uporlog into customize your list.

(potential Stack Overflow answerer) judge that? Where does research to solve a problem end and cheating start? Under what circumstances

@deceze When you then pretend that you did it alone and thats all your work: yes. But the other question is: who is not cheating on such challenges. I assume the most of them do.

What is the equivalent in arabic numbers of

Why do we not fly to space with helicopters? What are the practical altitude limits?

Can CBP confiscate documents when entering US?

Remove pixel patch in image which is stored as array

@deceze If you cant answer a challenge without help from others, then dont participate in that challenge. Challenges are supposed to test your skill and knowledge compared to other participants and not who asked first on SO. But again, I dont think that many other people care about that, thats why these challenges are quite useless (at least in my opinion).

Did Valerie Jarrett say she wanted America to be a more Islamic country?

You treat such questions like any other question.

ofStack Overflowand the software that powers it. You must have an account on Stack Overflow to participate.

How to make the signature/watermark look better?

Related: should I do someone elses homework?Mrs Johnson disagrees.

apt-add-repository: Command not found

From time to time I see questions, that ask for help in coding challenges and it is quite clear to me, that they do so. An example ishere. I feel somehow biased, if this kind of questions should be allowed on SO, because to me it feels like helping the person to cheat in the challenge, which is like doing someone elses homework. What to do with these kind of questions?

This question already has an answer here:

Money and Money, can two different currency types be realistically maintained in the same economy?

see also:Is there a need for a new flag type: Embargoed until contest closes at date/time?

I specify: Questions asking for homework help must include a summary of the work youve done so far to solve the problem, and a description of the difficulty you are having solving it. So, Ill use this as a guideline.

, then yes, thats cheating. But no developer works without constantly looking stuff up, so, yes, I agree that thats unrealistic and rather useless.

@deceze Looking something up is something different than asking someone else for help. Everyone can read the same resources available on the internet, but not everyone can access the same persons to ask them for help. This is way I would discourage that for challenges.

How many days does it reach hiking X miles per day?

Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us

I ask a question without it being cheating of some sort?

Not the answer youre looking for? Browse other questions tagged.

What is the logic behind forbidding LGBT conversion therapies?

How would you bring wealth back to the past?

It doesnt matter what the motivations are for asking a question. A good question is a good question, a bad question is a bad question, regardless of where the underlying problem originates from. If the question and its answers are useful to future visitors, it can stay. We are here for the long tail, after all.

Handle them like any other question.

Is helping me solve a coding problem Im stuck on at work help me cheat at work?

Plausible cause of a family only giving birth to females?

Asking for help for homework is clearly stated as being off-topic. Is a coding challenge comparable to homework?

Why would the bidding on a foreclosed property start at the outstanding amount of the loan?

site design / logo 2018 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed undercc by-sa 3.0withattribution required.rev2018.6.7.30694

: Not really /questions/334822/

Start here for a quick overview of the site

Who records Karma of all living beings?

How Meta is different from the main site

Detailed answers to any questions you might have

How can I align this equation in the center?

@Tom Sure, theres a distinction there. But again, theres a spectrum from researching a detail (may involve asking someone, depending on your arbitrarily decided rules) to having someone else complete the entire task. Theres no way we can make a judgement on where one ends and the other starts, besides our own definition of too broad questions we categorically dont answer, regardless of the context they were asked in.

Would a feat for expertise be balanced?

@Tom Personally I hardly care where a question originated from, if its a

Asking for help for homework is clearly stated as being off-topic is not true …

which would educate everyone, then Im not going to not answer it because I suspect it is being asked in the context of some coding challenge. Having said that, I think its unlikely that questions which can rather clearly be traced back to a challenge will be

Should a parent delete a teens social media account if it was handled badly?

@Tom If theres a restriction on the challenge la

may not use the internet or any external resource other than your own head

Good analogy needed: Sec issues due to different coders implementing the same features in different ways for the same app

; more often than not theyre poor to begin with. Good challenge questions probably wont appear as such. So this seems like a problem that mostly solves itself in practice.

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, pleaseask a new question.

Check if two strings are anagrams – implementation feedback

This site uses cookies to deliver our services and to show you relevant ads and job listings. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand ourCookie PolicyPrivacy Policy, and ourTerms of Service. Your use of Stack Overflows Products and Services, including the Stack Overflow Network, is subject to these policies and terms.

Why latex does not compile when two newlines are inserted in math mode?

The Stack Overflow community cant be tasked with enforcing third-party restrictions. Thats up to the third-party here, like the competition organisers. If the answers to such a question are used to break competition rules, that is a choice the question asker has to make, and up to the designated judges or referees of the competition to police.

Asking for help for homework is clearly stated as being off-topic

Learn more about Stack Overflow the company

Leave a Reply